"Cercetați toate lucrurile, si păstrați ce este bun!"

Apostolul Pavel

Having passed the stimulus bill, President Obama has recently turned his focus to the housing crisis. On February 18, the New York Times reported that, “Almost one in 10 home mortgages is either delinquent or in foreclosure, and analysts estimate that at as many as six million families could lose their homes over the next three years in the absence of government action.” Proposing $75 billion to keep people in their homes through refinancing and another $200 billion to avoid the collapse of government-controlled mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, Obama’s housing plan has spurred new controversies.
The key objection raised centers on whether responsible taxpayers who have played by the book should rescue those who were careless with their spending; and whether taxpayers should once again pick up the tab for Wall Street greed.

Perhaps it is a peculiarly human tendency to search for scapegoats in times of crisis. A lot of energy in the political sphere is being expended on identifying who is to blame. Time recently did a cover on the top 25 people responsible for the economic meltdown. The personas range from former Federal Reserve Chairman Allen Greenspan, who advocated for bank deregulation, to Chris Cox, the ex-chief of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) who failed to enforce even the lax regulations that remained. Number five on the list is the “American consumer” whose household debt has increased by more than 70% since 1982. (Funny that Time should measure the increase in consumer debt since 1982, because that was around the time the U.S. economy was coming out of another recession. One of the ways the U.S. got itself out of that recession was to increasing consumer debt ceilings to encourage more spending.)
           

There are some complex factors that contributed to this economic collapse. But what is really clear is that most people were pawns in a money game that was largely run by an elite few. To substantiate this point, allow me to state a few facts.
  • 1% of the U.S. population owns nearly 50% of country’s assets
  • 15% of population controls almost all of the country’s assets
  • 28,000 of the wealthiest people in the U.S. receive more income than 96 million of the nation’s poorest (see David Cay Johnston, Perfectly Legal, 2003)
  • 85% of $1 trillion increase in stock market valuation between 1989-1997 went to richest 10% of U.S. families (see William K. Tabb, The Amoral Elephant, 2001)


So, despite the fact that the majority of the U.S. population has seen falling wages, living standards and working conditions since 1980, the debate over housing foreclosures has shifted away from the rich elite and toward the “American consumer.” Frenzied politicians and citizens are trying to figure out how Obama’s housing plan will tell the difference between the “deserving” consumer that should be rescued from foreclosure and the “undeserving” consumer who should be left out to dry. To help discern the “deserving” from the “undeserving,” I thought I would devise a test.
1)       Do you have any credit card debt?
2)       Do you have any school loan debt?
3)       Do you have a car loan?
4)       Do you have a home equity loan?
5)       Do you think it is possible or likely that you will lose your job or business?
6)       Has the value of your home depreciated?
7)       Is your mortgage loan larger than the value of your home?

If you answered ‘yes’ to any of these questions, I imagine that this is what the ‘deserving’ would have to say to you, the ‘undeserving’…
 The Deserving: ‘You shouldn’t have gotten into all this debt. Now that you can’t make your payments, you expect to get a bailout from the government. That’s irresponsible!’
The Undeserving: ‘But the entire U.S. economy is structured on consumer debt! Besides, when I got into all those debts I had a good job with a good income. Now that I lost my job, I can’t make the payments.’
The Deserving: ‘Well, you’re clearly not working hard enough. Why don’t you go get a job?’
The Undeserving: ‘Because there are no jobs, the unemployment rate is over 10% and banks aren’t lending any more credit.’
The Deserving: ‘Well, then you just need to cut your losses and start over.’
The Undeserving: ‘But that means that I will end up homeless with my family.’
The Deserving: ‘Oh well!’ 

One month later…
 
The Deserving:
‘I can’t believe it! Even though I was totally responsible and didn’t have any debt except a 30-year fixed interest mortgage loan, I can’t keep up with my bills. Prescription medication, health insurance co-payments, my kid’s college tuition, utilities, gas, car insurance and food! I can’t keep up and I might lose my home… I guess I’ll just have to work harder, because I’ll never take any government handouts!’

There was only one problem for the Deserving… There were no jobs, no home equity loans, and no credit. 

Forgive the rhetorical sarcasm, but I am hoping that the faulty logic of this deserving/undeserving game is coming into focus. The problem is that today’s ‘deserving-hard-working-taxpayer-who-plays-by-the-book’ is tomorrow’s unemployed parent who will lose her home and livelihood. Approaching a structural problem that affects everyone by trying to decipher which American consumers are ‘worthy’ of help is like trying to rescue individuals from a sinking boat.
           

The debate over who deserves to be rescued and who does not has exhumed a fundamental contradiction in American values and culture. Crises like this are very difficult in a country that has a long tradition of rugged individualism. They are difficult because people aren’t used to thinking of themselves in relation to others, as inter-dependent rather than isolated units. This crisis has shown that there is very little political and economic value attributed to communal networks of support; and that the U.S. is remarkably out of practice when it comes to thinking about how to raise everyone up rather than structuring policies that benefit only a select few. We have an economic crisis that affects everyone, yet we keep trying to tackle it from an individualist standpoint of ‘How can I save myself and let others fall?’ But as my mock dialogue illustrates, the one who saves himself today may very well be the one that falls tomorrow.
           

I want to make clear, however, that I am talking about working and workless people. Corporations, banks, investment firms and the richest 10% of the population have demonstrated that their modus operandi is to continue to pursue their interests at all costs, and at the expense of the people.  This is why governmental policies—including temporary receivership of banks—must shift from an approach that asks for cooperation to one that requires these entities to relinquish their interests in order to save people’s livelihoods.


Though this approach is economically necessary, it is still politically unviable. The reason politics has trumped economics thus far has to do with a faulty ideological association between temporary government control of banks and the “s” word. But as those of us from Eastern Europe know all too well, governments and people have often chosen to hold onto dogmatic ideologies (in this case rugged individualism and deregulated free market logic) instead of acing to save people’s well being.

 

Diverse

Mesajul de Paști al Președintelui TRUMP

on 16 Aprilie 2020

10 aprilie 2020 ora 12:09 PM (ora locală)PREȘEDINTELE:„Vă mulțumesc foarte mult...

Alegeri pentru Parlamentul României - 2020

on 02 Aprilie 2020

Cetățenii români cu drept de vot, cu domiciliul sau reședința în străinătate, ca...

CRIZA COVID-19 - Prelungirea VIZEI DE ȘEDERE ÎN SU...

on 19 Martie 2020

Toți cei interesați puteți accesa acest site unde veți găsi formularul și instru...

Permisul de conducere international

on 19 Martie 2020

Tipul de permis de conducere care se poate folosi în România dacă conducătorul a...

Pensionari români scutiți de impozit

on 18 Martie 2020

La primul forum media organizat de publicația RomanianTimes, sâmbătă 8 februarie...

O transformare tăcută dar puternică a SUA cu efect...

on 18 Martie 2020

Când președintele Statelor Unite Donald J. Trump amintește realizările de la pre...

Meditatii crestine

Camera de sus - Cina Domnului cu ucenicii Săi

on 25 Martie 2024

 „Învățătorul îți zice: „Unde este odaia pentru oaspeți, în care să mănânc Paște...

Recenzia cărții Birul Cezarului și dreptul lui Dum...

on 23 Februarie 2024

Așa cum mi-am format obiceiul să-mi ridic poșta din căsuța poștală a casei în ju...

Semne ale vremurilor: Israel - „Never Again!”

on 21 Ianuarie 2024

La această rubrică de peste 20 de ani am scris și scriu ori de câte ori apar eve...

Înălțimile Golan și Ispitirea Domnului

on 21 Ianuarie 2024

„Au dat fiilor lui Gherşon dintre familiile leviţilor: din cealaltă jumătate a s...

Câmpul păstorilor din Betleem

on 21 Decembrie 2023

În ținutul acela, erau niște păstori care stăteau afară, în câmp, şi făceau de s...

Lansare de carte - BIRUL CEZARULUI și dreptul lui...

on 22 Noiembrie 2023

IntroducereStudiul de față este rezultatul dorinței de a clarifica această porun...

Orașe SUA

Vizita ambasadorului României în statele americane...

on 25 Martie 2024

Întâlniri cu comunitățile de români și întrevederi cu oficiali ai celor doua sta...

ISRAEL… Note de Drum (6)

on 24 Martie 2024

Ierusalim: Muntele Măslinilor, Grădina Ghetsimani, Pârâul Chedron, Cetatea, Via...

ISRAEL… Note de Drum (5)

on 23 Februarie 2024

Haifa – Marea Galileii Pornim la drum, de la Haifa, spre Marea Galileii. Caperna...

Lumina si culoare-interviu cu pictorul Timisoarei,...

on 23 Februarie 2024

“Arta te face mai bun, iti curata spiritul si te inalta spre divinitate…” ~ Seba...

ISRAEL… Note de Drum (4)

on 21 Ianuarie 2024

De la Ierusalim la Beer Sheeva și Muntele Carmel De la Ierusalim suntem pe drumu...

Părinții Americii - Alexandru Hamilton

on 21 Ianuarie 2024

“Nu ma astept niciodata la un lucru perfect de la un om imperfect.” ~ Alexandru...

Cultura

Sosirea Regilor României la Frasin

on 25 Martie 2024

În așteptarea minunilor, prințesă în regatul copilăriei Am pășit pe urmele regil...

Idolul politicos al Bisericii

on 25 Martie 2024

In ultimii 3 ani am gandit si interactionat pe marginea intrebarii despre cum a...

Limba de cultură, ethosul și înstrăinările

on 23 Februarie 2024

I. Destinul ultimului mohicanO temă fascinantă: jocurile copilului și ethosul tr...

Marmota pare simpatică dar nu ajută sufletul

on 23 Februarie 2024

Pana sa ajung in partea asta de lume nu am stiu de Ziua Marmotei. Stiam despre a...

Geniul : între mistică, legendă și victimele mitul...

on 21 Ianuarie 2024

Evocarea lui Mihai Eminescu la Ziua Culturii Naționale invită la numeroase itine...

Crize si binecuvantari

on 21 Ianuarie 2024

Crize si binecuvantari. Acestea sunt coordonatele reale ale vietii multora dintr...

Politica

Israel - în război de apărare pe trei fronturi

on 20 Octombrie 2023

O situație fără precedent, în Israel, când cel de-al 37-lea guvern era într-o pe...

Ținta FEM: Fără carne și lactate, mai puține haine...

on 24 August 2023

Semne ale vremurilor sunt evenimente unice ale zilelor noastre cu corespondență...

Semne ale vremurilor din urmă – SEMNE în SOARE

on 28 Iulie 2023

Semne ale vremurilor din urmă sunt evenimente unice ale zilelor noastre cu cores...

Inteligența Artificială folosită să predice, să re...

on 23 Iunie 2023

Semne ale vremurilor din urmă Semne ale vremurilor din urmă sunt evenimente unic...

Semne ale vremurilor din urmă

on 23 Martie 2023

Am scris și altădată că nu vă voi prezenta vremuri din urmă ci SEMNE ale vremuri...

Votul tău este foarte important pentru America

on 27 Octombrie 2022

Suntem din nou în fața unor decizii care ne vor afecta pe noi și familiile noast...